Skip to main content
Exciting events happening at Hartville & Middlefield! Learn More
Hartville Hardware & Lumber Logo
0 item(s) in your cart.
  • Back
  • In-store & Online
  • Deals by Brand
  • Deals by Price
  • In-store Only
  • Flyers
  • Back
  • Shop by Department

Site Map

Chalk & Milk Paints
Olde Century Colors Tavern Yellow Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Quart Olde Century Colors Tavern Yellow Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Quart
Olde Century Colors Manor House White Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Quart Olde Century Colors Manor House White Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Quart
Olde Century Colors Firethorn Acrylic Latex Paint, 2 oz. Olde Century Colors Firethorn Acrylic Latex Paint, 2 oz.
Olde Century Colors Salem Gray Acrylic Latex Paint, 2 oz. Olde Century Colors Salem Gray Acrylic Latex Paint, 2 oz.
Olde Century Colors Goldenrod Yellow Acrylic Latex Paint, 2 oz. Olde Century Colors Goldenrod Yellow Acrylic Latex Paint, 2 oz.
Olde Century Colors Bittersweet Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Quart Olde Century Colors Bittersweet Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Quart
Olde Century Colors Cranberry Acrylic Latex Paint, 2 oz. Olde Century Colors Cranberry Acrylic Latex Paint, 2 oz.
Olde Century Colors Olde Navy Acrylic Latex Paint, 2 oz. Olde Century Colors Olde Navy Acrylic Latex Paint, 2 oz.
Olde Century Colors Red Acrylic Latex Paint, 2 oz. Olde Century Colors Red Acrylic Latex Paint, 2 oz.
Olde Century Colors Cupboard Blue Acrylic Latex Paint, 2 oz. Olde Century Colors Cupboard Blue Acrylic Latex Paint, 2 oz.
Olde Century Colors Yankee Blue Acrylic Latex Paint, 2 oz. Olde Century Colors Yankee Blue Acrylic Latex Paint, 2 oz.
Olde Century Colors Quaker Green Acrylic Latex Paint, 2 oz. Olde Century Colors Quaker Green Acrylic Latex Paint, 2 oz.
Olde Century Colors Olde Ivory Acrylic Latex Paint, 2 oz. Olde Century Colors Olde Ivory Acrylic Latex Paint, 2 oz.
Olde Century Colors Union Blue Acrylic Latex Paint, 2 oz. Olde Century Colors Union Blue Acrylic Latex Paint, 2 oz.
Olde Century Colors Brownstone Acrylic Latex Paint, 2 oz. Olde Century Colors Brownstone Acrylic Latex Paint, 2 oz.
Olde Century Colors Olde Farm White Acrylic Latex Paint, 2 oz. Olde Century Colors Olde Farm White Acrylic Latex Paint, 2 oz.
Olde Century Colors Windsor Chair Green Acrylic Latex Paint, 2 oz. Olde Century Colors Windsor Chair Green Acrylic Latex Paint, 2 oz.
Olde Century Colors Greenbrier Acrylic Latex Paint, 2 oz. Olde Century Colors Greenbrier Acrylic Latex Paint, 2 oz.
Olde Century Colors Barn Red Acrylic Latex Paint, 2 oz. Olde Century Colors Barn Red Acrylic Latex Paint, 2 oz.
Olde Century Colors Plymouth Blue Acrylic Latex Paint, 2 oz. Olde Century Colors Plymouth Blue Acrylic Latex Paint, 2 oz.
Olde Century Colors Linen White Acrylic Latex Paint, 2 oz. Olde Century Colors Linen White Acrylic Latex Paint, 2 oz.
Olde Century Colors Olde Brick Red Acrylic Latex Paint, 2 oz. Olde Century Colors Olde Brick Red Acrylic Latex Paint, 2 oz.
Olde Century Colors Olde Pewter Acrylic Latex Paint, 2 oz. Olde Century Colors Olde Pewter Acrylic Latex Paint, 2 oz.
Olde Century Colors Brierwood Green Acrylic Latex Paint, 2 oz. Olde Century Colors Brierwood Green Acrylic Latex Paint, 2 oz.
Olde Century Colors Olde Forge Mustard Acrylic Latex Paint, 2 oz. Olde Century Colors Olde Forge Mustard Acrylic Latex Paint, 2 oz.
Olde Century Colors Manor House White Acrylic Latex Paint, 2 oz. Olde Century Colors Manor House White Acrylic Latex Paint, 2 oz.
Olde Century Colors Lantern Glow Acrylic Latex Paint, 2 oz. Olde Century Colors Lantern Glow Acrylic Latex Paint, 2 oz.
Olde Century Colors Candleberry Green Acrylic Latex Paint, 2 oz. Olde Century Colors Candleberry Green Acrylic Latex Paint, 2 oz.
Olde Century Colors Bittersweet Acrylic Latex Paint, 2 oz. Olde Century Colors Bittersweet Acrylic Latex Paint, 2 oz.
Olde Century Colors Buttermilk Acrylic Latex Paint, 2 oz. Olde Century Colors Buttermilk Acrylic Latex Paint, 2 oz.
Olde Century Colors Fenwick Yellow Acrylic Latex Paint, 2 oz. Olde Century Colors Fenwick Yellow Acrylic Latex Paint, 2 oz.
Olde Century Colors Cobblestone Acrylic Latex Paint, 2 oz. Olde Century Colors Cobblestone Acrylic Latex Paint, 2 oz.
Olde Century Colors Tavern Yellow Acrylic Latex Paint, 2 oz. Olde Century Colors Tavern Yellow Acrylic Latex Paint, 2 oz.
Olde Century Colors Candlelight Acrylic Latex Paint, 2 oz. Olde Century Colors Candlelight Acrylic Latex Paint, 2 oz.
Olde Century Colors Greenbrier Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Quart Olde Century Colors Greenbrier Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Quart
Olde Century Colors Linen White Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Quart Olde Century Colors Linen White Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Quart
Olde Century Colors Lamp Black Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Quart Olde Century Colors Lamp Black Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Quart
Olde Century Colors Olde Pewter Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Quart Olde Century Colors Olde Pewter Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Quart
Olde Century Colors Candleberry Green Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Quart Olde Century Colors Candleberry Green Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Quart
Olde Century Colors Cranberry Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Pint. Olde Century Colors Cranberry Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Pint.
Olde Century Colors Cupboard Blue Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Pint Olde Century Colors Cupboard Blue Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Pint
Olde Century Colors Yankee Blue Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Pint Olde Century Colors Yankee Blue Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Pint
Olde Century Colors Revere Green Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Pint Olde Century Colors Revere Green Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Pint
Olde Century Colors Quaker Green Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Pint Olde Century Colors Quaker Green Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Pint
Olde Century Colors Union Blue Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Pint Olde Century Colors Union Blue Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Pint
Olde Century Colors Brownstone Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Pint Olde Century Colors Brownstone Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Pint
Olde Century Colors Tinderbox Brown Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Pint Olde Century Colors Tinderbox Brown Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Pint
Olde Century Colors Olde Farm White Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Pint Olde Century Colors Olde Farm White Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Pint
Olde Century Colors Windsor Chair Green Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Pint Olde Century Colors Windsor Chair Green Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Pint
Olde Century Colors Salt Box Blue Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Pint Olde Century Colors Salt Box Blue Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Pint
Olde Century Colors Greenbriar Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Pint Olde Century Colors Greenbriar Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Pint
Olde Century Colors Old Navy Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Pint Olde Century Colors Old Navy Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Pint
Olde Century Colors Barn Red Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Pint Olde Century Colors Barn Red Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Pint
Olde Century Colors Plymouth Blue Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Pint Olde Century Colors Plymouth Blue Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Pint
Olde Century Colors Linen White Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Pint Olde Century Colors Linen White Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Pint
Olde Century Colors Thistle Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Pint Olde Century Colors Thistle Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Pint
Olde Century Colors Olde Brick Red Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Pint. Olde Century Colors Olde Brick Red Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Pint.
Olde Century Colors Lamp Black Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Pint Olde Century Colors Lamp Black Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Pint
Olde Century Colors Olde Pewter Acrylic Latex Paint, Pint Olde Century Colors Olde Pewter Acrylic Latex Paint, Pint
Olde Century Colors Brierwood Green Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Pint Olde Century Colors Brierwood Green Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Pint
Olde Century Colors Goldenrod Yellow Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Pint Olde Century Colors Goldenrod Yellow Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Pint
Olde Century Colors Manor House White Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Pint Olde Century Colors Manor House White Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Pint
Olde Century Colors Lantern Glow Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Pint Olde Century Colors Lantern Glow Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Pint
Olde Century Colors Buttermilk Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Pint Olde Century Colors Buttermilk Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Pint
Olde Century Colors Cobblestone Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Pint Olde Century Colors Cobblestone Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Pint
Olde Century Colors Candlelight Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Pint Olde Century Colors Candlelight Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Pint
Olde Century Colors Olde Sage Green Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Pint Olde Century Colors Olde Sage Green Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Pint
Olde Century Colors Brownstone Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Quart Olde Century Colors Brownstone Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Quart
Olde Century Colors Cranberry Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Quart Olde Century Colors Cranberry Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Quart
Olde Century Colors Union Blue Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Quart Olde Century Colors Union Blue Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Quart
Olde Century Colors Revere Green Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Quart Olde Century Colors Revere Green Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Quart
Olde Century Colors Yankee Blue Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Quart Olde Century Colors Yankee Blue Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Quart
Olde Century Colors Olde Ivory Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Quart Olde Century Colors Olde Ivory Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Quart
Olde Century Colors Olde Farm White Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Quart Olde Century Colors Olde Farm White Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Quart
Olde Century Colors Olde Sage Green Acrylic Latex Paint, 2 oz. Olde Century Colors Olde Sage Green Acrylic Latex Paint, 2 oz.
Olde Century Colors Plymouth Blue Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Quart Olde Century Colors Plymouth Blue Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Quart
Olde Century Colors Olde Forge Mustard Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Quart Olde Century Colors Olde Forge Mustard Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Quart
Olde Century Colors Red Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Quart Olde Century Colors Red Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Quart
Olde Century Colors Quaker Green Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Quart Olde Century Colors Quaker Green Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Quart
Olde Century Colors Windsor Chair Green Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Quart Olde Century Colors Windsor Chair Green Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Quart
Olde Century Colors Tinderbox Brown Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Quart Olde Century Colors Tinderbox Brown Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Quart
Olde Century Colors Olde Navy Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Quart Olde Century Colors Olde Navy Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Quart
Olde Century Colors Barn Red Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Quart Olde Century Colors Barn Red Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Quart
Olde Century Colors Lantern Glow Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Quart Olde Century Colors Lantern Glow Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Quart
Olde Century Colors Buttermilk Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Quart Olde Century Colors Buttermilk Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Quart
Olde Century Colors Cobblestone Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Quart Olde Century Colors Cobblestone Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Quart
Olde Century Colors Old Brick Red Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Quart Olde Century Colors Old Brick Red Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Quart
Olde Century Colors Salt Box Blue Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Quart Olde Century Colors Salt Box Blue Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Quart
Olde Century Colors Savanna Red Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Quart Olde Century Colors Savanna Red Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Quart
Olde Century Colors Candlelight Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Quart Olde Century Colors Candlelight Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Quart
Olde Century Colors Goldenrod Yellow Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Quart Olde Century Colors Goldenrod Yellow Acrylic Latex Paint, 1 Quart
Rust-Oleum Chalked Country Gray Ultra Matte Chalk Paint, 30 oz. Rust-Oleum Chalked Country Gray Ultra Matte Chalk Paint, 30 oz.
Rust-Oleum Chalked Aged Gray Ultra Matte Chalk Paint, 30 oz. Rust-Oleum Chalked Aged Gray Ultra Matte Chalk Paint, 30 oz.
Rust-Oleum Chalked Chalk Paint Rust-Oleum Chalked Chalk Paint
Rust-Oleum Chalked Chalk Paint Rust-Oleum Chalked Chalk Paint
Rust-Oleum Chalked Serenity Blue Ultra Matte Chalk Paint, 30 oz. Rust-Oleum Chalked Serenity Blue Ultra Matte Chalk Paint, 30 oz.
Rust-Oleum Chalked Linen White Ultra Matte Chalk Paint, 30 oz. Rust-Oleum Chalked Linen White Ultra Matte Chalk Paint, 30 oz.
Rust-Oleum Chalked Charcoal Ultra Matte Chalk Paint, 30 oz. Rust-Oleum Chalked Charcoal Ultra Matte Chalk Paint, 30 oz.
Rust-Oleum Chalked Matte Clear Protective Topcoat, 30 oz. Rust-Oleum Chalked Matte Clear Protective Topcoat, 30 oz.
Rust-Oleum Chalked Ultra Matte Chiffon Cream Chalk Paint, 30 oz. Rust-Oleum Chalked Ultra Matte Chiffon Cream Chalk Paint, 30 oz.
General Finishes Coral Crush Milk Paint, Pint General Finishes Coral Crush Milk Paint, Pint
General Finishes Emerald Milk Paint, Pint General Finishes Emerald Milk Paint, Pint
General Finishes Holiday Red Milk Paint, Pint General Finishes Holiday Red Milk Paint, Pint
General Finishes Patina Green Milk Paint, Pint General Finishes Patina Green Milk Paint, Pint
General Finishes Queenstown Gray Milk Paint, Pint General Finishes Queenstown Gray Milk Paint, Pint
General Finishes Antique White Water Based Milk Paint, 1 Quart General Finishes Antique White Water Based Milk Paint, 1 Quart
General Finishes Lamp Black Water Based Milk Paint, Quart General Finishes Lamp Black Water Based Milk Paint, Quart
General Finishes Seagull Gray Milk Paint, Quart General Finishes Seagull Gray Milk Paint, Quart
General Finishes Linen Water Based Milk Paint, Quart General Finishes Linen Water Based Milk Paint, Quart
General Finishes Queenstown Gray Milk Paint, Quart General Finishes Queenstown Gray Milk Paint, Quart
General Finishes Basil Water Based Milk Paint, 1 Quart General Finishes Basil Water Based Milk Paint, 1 Quart
General Finishes Klein Blue Water Based Milk Paint, Quart General Finishes Klein Blue Water Based Milk Paint, Quart
General Finishes Antique White Milk Paint, 1 Pint General Finishes Antique White Milk Paint, 1 Pint
General Finishes Basil Milk Paint, 1 Pint  General Finishes Basil Milk Paint, 1 Pint
General Finishes Coastal Blue Milk Paint, Pint General Finishes Coastal Blue Milk Paint, Pint
General Finishes Lamp Black Milk Paint, Pint General Finishes Lamp Black Milk Paint, Pint
General Finishes Snow White Milk Paint, Pint General Finishes Snow White Milk Paint, Pint
General Finishes Dark Chocolate Water Based Milk Paint, Pint General Finishes Dark Chocolate Water Based Milk Paint, Pint
General Finishes Persian Blue Water Based Milk Paint, Pint  General Finishes Persian Blue Water Based Milk Paint, Pint
General Finishes Seagull Gray Milk Paint, Pint General Finishes Seagull Gray Milk Paint, Pint
Olde Century Salem Gray Simulated Milk Paint, Quart Olde Century Salem Gray Simulated Milk Paint, Quart
Olde Century Salem Gray Simulated Milk Paint, Pint Olde Century Salem Gray Simulated Milk Paint, Pint
Olde Century Carriage Black Simulated Milk Paint, Pint Olde Century Carriage Black Simulated Milk Paint, Pint
Olde Century 2020 Acrylic Latex Paint Thistle, 2 oz. Olde Century 2020 Acrylic Latex Paint Thistle, 2 oz.
Rust-Oleum Blush Pink Ultra Matte Chalked Paint, 30 oz. Rust-Oleum Blush Pink Ultra Matte Chalked Paint, 30 oz.
Rust-Oleum Coastal Blue Ultra Matte Chalked Paint, 30 oz.  Rust-Oleum Coastal Blue Ultra Matte Chalked Paint, 30 oz.
Rust-Oleum Farmhouse Red Ultra Matte Chalked Paint, 30 oz.  Rust-Oleum Farmhouse Red Ultra Matte Chalked Paint, 30 oz.
Rust-Oleum Tate Green Ultra Matte Chalked Spray Paint, 12 oz. Rust-Oleum Tate Green Ultra Matte Chalked Spray Paint, 12 oz.
Rust-Oleum Blue Harbor Ultra Matte Chalked Spray Paint, 12 oz. Rust-Oleum Blue Harbor Ultra Matte Chalked Spray Paint, 12 oz.
Olde Century Olde Forge Mustard Acrylic Latex Paint, Pint Olde Century Olde Forge Mustard Acrylic Latex Paint, Pint
General Finishes Sunglow Milk Paint, Pint General Finishes Sunglow Milk Paint, Pint
General Finishes Snow White Milk Paint, Quart General Finishes Snow White Milk Paint, Quart
General Finishes Dark Chocolate Water Based Milk Paint, Quart General Finishes Dark Chocolate Water Based Milk Paint, Quart
General Finishes Tuscan Red Milk Paint, 1 Pint General Finishes Tuscan Red Milk Paint, 1 Pint
General Finishes Driftwood Milk Paint, Pint General Finishes Driftwood Milk Paint, Pint
General Finishes Halycon Blue Milk Paint, Pint General Finishes Halycon Blue Milk Paint, Pint
General Finishes Klein Blue Milk Paint, Pint General Finishes Klein Blue Milk Paint, Pint
General Finishes Antique White Milk Paint, 1 Gallon General Finishes Antique White Milk Paint, 1 Gallon
General Finishes Snow White Milk Paint, Gallon General Finishes Snow White Milk Paint, Gallon
General Finishes Driftwood Water Based Milk Paint, Quart General Finishes Driftwood Water Based Milk Paint, Quart
General Finishes Millstone Water Based Milk Paint, Quart General Finishes Millstone Water Based Milk Paint, Quart
General Finishes Linen Milk Paint, Pint General Finishes Linen Milk Paint, Pint
General Finishes Millstone Milk Paint, Pint General Finishes Millstone Milk Paint, Pint
General Finishes Somerset Gold Milk Paint, Pint General Finishes Somerset Gold Milk Paint, Pint
General Finishes Linen Milk Paint, Gallon General Finishes Linen Milk Paint, Gallon
General Finishes Lamp Black Milk Paint, Gallon General Finishes Lamp Black Milk Paint, Gallon
Olde Century Pt2037 Acrylic Latex Paint Firethorn Pint Olde Century Pt2037 Acrylic Latex Paint Firethorn Pint
Olde Century Pt3003 Simulated Milk Paint Cottage Rose Pint Olde Century Pt3003 Simulated Milk Paint Cottage Rose Pint
Olde Century Holly Berry Red Simulated Milk Paint, 1 Pint Olde Century Holly Berry Red Simulated Milk Paint, 1 Pint
Olde Century Pt3012 Simulated Milk Paint Holly Hill Green Pint Olde Century Pt3012 Simulated Milk Paint Holly Hill Green Pint
Olde Century Olde Ivory Acrylic Latex Paint, Pint Olde Century Olde Ivory Acrylic Latex Paint, Pint
Olde Century Simulated Milk Paint Olde Parchment, 1 Pint Olde Century Simulated Milk Paint Olde Parchment, 1 Pint
Olde Century Dark Mallard Blue Simulated Milk Paint, 1 Pint Olde Century Dark Mallard Blue Simulated Milk Paint, 1 Pint
Olde Century Morovian White Simulated Milk Paint, Pint Olde Century Morovian White Simulated Milk Paint, Pint
Olde Century Olde Mustard Simulated Milk Paint, Pint Olde Century Olde Mustard Simulated Milk Paint, Pint

We're here to help

If you need help with an online order or have questions about the website, please call us Monday-Friday; 8am-6pm or Saturday 8am-4pm, EST.

1-800-345-2396 or Email us anytime→

This Site Uses Cookies We use tracking cookies to provide a better experience for you. These cookies allow us to personalize content and collect browsing data that helps improve our web pages. The information we collect from your visit is securely stored and never shared.

Accept Do not accept