• Old fashioned peanut butter stirrer with wooden handle in kitchen utensils and kitchenware collections under $50
  • Vintage-style handheld peanut butter stirrer with metal crank and white handle in Kitchen Utensils under $50 collection
  • Vintage-style peanut butter stirrer with curved metal crank and white handle in Kitchenware and Cooking Utensils under $50 collections
  • Old fashioned peanut butter stirrer with white handle twisting oil in a jar, part of kitchen utensils under $50 collection
  • Vintage style peanut butter stirrer with metal crank and red circular body in Kitchenware and Cooking Utensils under $50 collections
  • Old fashioned peanut butter stirrer with red circular body and white handle in Kitchenware and Kitchen Utensils under $50 collections
  • Red-topped old fashioned peanut butter stirrer with white handle on a jar of organic creamy peanut butter in Kitchenware collection
  • Handheld peanut butter stirrer with red circular body and white handle in Kitchenware and Kitchen Utensils collections under $50
  • Red circular hand crank with white handle for stirring peanut butter in Kitchenware and Kitchen Utensils under $50 collections
  • Red old fashioned peanut butter stirrer with metal crank handle and white grip atop jar of creamy peanut butter on red and white checkered cloth, in Kitchenware and Cooking Utensils under $50 collections.
  • Disassembled peanut butter stirrer with red circular top, metal crank, and white handle in Kitchenware and Utensils collections under $50
1 12
In Store Only IN-STORE ONLY Made in USA

Old Fashioned Peanut Butter Stirrer

Old Fashioned Peanut Butter Stirrer

SKU: 54322

Shop All Rw witmer
Add to Favorites
$21.94
Variety
BENEFITS OF PEANUT BUTTER STIRRERS Prevent oily messes with a peanut butter stirrer from Lehman's. The oil in non-hydrogenated peanut butter naturally separates over time, but Grandpa Witmer's Old Fashioned Peanut Butter Mixer stirs the oil back into the peanut butter. Prevents an oily mess Easy to use with your favorite peanut butter Molded plastic knob Does not fit all peanut butter jars, please measure lid diameter before purchasing! Made in USA
View full details

Technical Specs Technical Specs

Overview
BENEFITS OF PEANUT BUTTER STIRRERS Prevent oily messes with a peanut butter stirrer from Lehman's. The oil in non-hydrogenated peanut butter naturally separates over time, but Grandpa Witmer's Old Fashioned Peanut Butter Mixer stirs the oil back into the peanut butter. Prevents an oily mess Easy to use with your favorite peanut butter Molded plastic knob Does not fit all peanut butter jars, please measure lid diameter before purchasing! Made in USA

Customers Also Viewed

Illustration of a hand truck tilted back with three stacked red cardboard boxes of varying sizes ready for transport.

Flexible Pickup & Delivery

Find a lower price on an exact item? We'll match it. Some exclusions apply.

Learn More
Shield outline in black containing a large red checkmark, representing safety and trust in home improvement and tools.

Authorized Dealer

We are an authorized dealer of several top brands, providing high-quality products with unmatched service.

Learn More
Two red brushstroke shapes forming a stylized heart outline against a transparent background, symbolizing care or love.

Family-Owned

We are a fourth-generation family-owned business built on community, trust, and family values.

Learn More
Illustration of a house outline with a red heart shape integrated above the Hartville Hardware Lumber name, symbolizing community commitment in home improvement.

Price Pledge

We will price-match items our customers find at local competitors for less money on in-store and online purchases.

Learn More