Long display wall filled with organized paint color swatches arranged by hue in a home improvement store setting.

Paint Center

Sometimes, the best ideas start with a paint swatch. At Hartville Hardware, we have over 3,500 shades of house paint to choose from, plus we color match to make the custom hue of your choosing - making your options truly limitless. Not sure whether you want a matte finish or a glossier sheen? Our in-store sheen displays can help you choose. Our paint department is massive and includes craft paints, spray paints, stains, primers, and heavy-duty specialty paints. Our paint department also includes caulk, sealant, glue, and concrete, plus, of course, all the tools of the painting trade - from rollers to brushes to paint sprayers to paint removal products. Whether your project is as tiny as a model airplane wheel or as big as a house, the Paint Center at Hartville Hardware has everything you need.

Find the Right Paint For the Job

Interior Paint

Bright mudroom with built-in white storage cabinets, a cushioned bench with pillows, hooks holding bags and coats, and a small dog sitting on the bench.

The colors you choose for your home's interiors will set the tone and mood of your home for years to come, so your options should be limitless. Select a color palette from the thousands of color samples in-store, or bring in a color sample so that we can color-match it. Bring a photo of your antique quilt and create a color combination based on it, or bring your little one's favorite stuffed toy to design a custom paint color for their room. You can even buy a 16 oz. sample of any color you create to make sure it looks right in your home. With finishes like satin, matte, eggshell, flat, and pearl, we have the right interior paint for you.

Shop

Exterior Paint

Front entrance with a gray paneled door framed by white classical trim, flanked by black outdoor lanterns and potted plants on stone steps.

We only carry paint we'd be willing to use on our own houses, and that means our exterior paints have to be rugged, dependable, and naturally, they have to look great. We don't tolerate cracking, peeling, blistering, or fading, and it has to resist irritants like mildew. Choose from thousands of colors, or bring your own sample so we can color match it. Whether you prefer flat, low luster, satin, or gloss, you will find what you are looking for here in our store. Looking to paint hardboard, vinyl / aluminum siding, shingles, unglazed brick, concrete, stucco, cinder block, or primed metal? You're looking in the right spot. Tell a sales associate what surface you want to paint on, and they'll help you find the best paint for the job.

Shop

Can of Benjamin Moore Woodluxe semi-solid water-based exterior wood stain and sealer with green and brown labeling designed for home improvement and wood protection.

Exterior Stain & Sealer

 Metal can of Zar interior oil-based wood stain in a muted gray shade labeled

Interior Wood Stain

 Can of white interior water-based primer labeled for sealing and preparing walls, shown with application images for home improvement use.

Primer

 Two cans of Rust-Oleum spray paint, one in turquoise and the other in charcoal black, used for home improvement and DIY projects.

Spray Paint
Bag of Homax Tough Tile tile, caulk, and grime remover with white and blue packaging used for home improvement cleaning tasks

Countertop, Tile & Tub Refinishing

 Two small bottles of craft paint, one in white and the other in coral pink, with colorful labels and white flip-top caps.

Craft Paints

 Box of Rust-Oleum RockSolid metallic floor coating featuring protective finish for garage and workshop surfaces with high durability claims.

Floor Paint & Epoxies

 Can of Rust-Oleum Chalked paint in a muted gray shade labeled

Chalk & Milk Paint
SHOP ALL PAINTS
Illustration of a smiling woman with short dark hair and glasses wearing a black collared shirt featuring a small red heart emblem on the chest

Talk with one of our experts!

Paint with confidence with help from Hartville Hardware. Our experts are always on-hand to answer questions about our paints and painting tools. Trying to figure out the difference between flat and matte paint finishes? We can show you. Not quite sure how to paint with a roller? We'll help you find the right tools and make sure you know how to use them. We'll even help you find a reputable house painting service near your home.

FIND A LOCATIONCONTACT US

TOP PAINTING TOOLS

Professional paint roller cover with a tightly woven fabric designed for smooth application of semi-gloss paints in home improvement projects.

Roller Covers & Frames

 Red and black handheld paper pad applicator with a curved edge, designed for smooth paint application during home improvement tasks.

Paint Pads

 Long wooden drywall taping pole with a metal end and black grip, used for reaching high walls during home improvement projects.

Paint Poles

 Cordless blue and gray handheld paint sprayer with an attached clear paint container and battery pack, designed for home improvement tasks.

Paint Sprayers
Two paintbrushes side by side, one with natural bristles and a wooden handle, the other with a black foam head and a wooden handle.

Foam & Chip Brushes

 Paintbrush with light wooden handle and white bristles displayed upright against a plain white background, suitable for home improvement and painting tasks.

Synthetic Brushes

 Wide paintbrush with natural bristles and a black plastic handle, suitable for various home improvement and painting tasks.

Natural Brushes

SHOP PAINTING TOOLS

Blue polyethylene tarp folded with a red label displaying size dimensions and usage details for home improvement and outdoor protection tasks

Tarps & Drop Cloths

 Set of disposable paint trays with metallic silver finish, including multiple black plastic liners and a red-handled paint stirrer, suitable for home improvement projects.

Roller Trays & Liners

 Roll of blue painter’s tape with white and blue labeling, designed for masking surfaces during home improvement and painting tasks.

Painting Tape

 Red plastic bucket with a white lid featuring the Hartville Hardware and Lumber logo, used for storage or home improvement tasks.

Paint Buckets
Bottle of Titebond Original wood glue with a red twist cap, designed for strong adhesive bonding in woodworking and home improvement tasks.

Adhesives & Glue

 White plastic container with a yellow label reading

Paint Thinners & Solvents

 Large plastic container of Citristrip paint and varnish stripping gel with a green label and orange liquid inside, used for home improvement projects.

Paint Removal

 Tube of red and white Kwik Seal caulking sealant with a white nozzle, standing upright on a plain white background.

Caulk & Sealants

 Yellow and red cardboard dispenser box labeled

Rags & PPE

 Orange fiberglass step ladder with six wide aluminum steps and yellow safety feet, designed for home improvement and tool use.

Ladders & Step Stools
Living room setup with a gray sofa, throw pillows, and a glass vase holding flowering branches, accompanied by a palette of muted paint colors and text about 2025 color trends.
SHOP COLOR TRENDS

SHOP OUR BEST SELLING BRANDS

Benjamin Moore logo featuring a red stylized mountain peak above blue bold lettering on a white background, representing paint and home improvement. Red and white logo for The Wooster Brush Company featuring bold lettering with a stylized brush stroke above the Black and red Rust-Oleum logo featuring a bold serif font and a four-square red graphic symbolizing paint and home improvement. Rectangular logo with a black background featuring the gold text

DRYWALL REPAIR

Black and red package of fine 120 grit sandpaper sheets branded Bob Best Professional, used for home improvement and woodworking tasks.

Sandpaper

 Putty knife with a flexible metal blade and black plastic handle, designed for smoothing and applying materials in home improvement tasks.

Putty Knives & Jab Saws

 Roll of white self-adhesive drywall joint tape with red label, used for reinforcing drywall seams in home improvement projects.

Drywall Tape

 White plastic bucket with a green lid labeled all purpose joint compound, used for drywall and home improvement tasks.

Joint Compound
Rectangular gray metal mud pan used for holding joint compound during drywall and home improvement projects.

Mud Pans & Drywall Hawks

 Compact electric drywall sander with extendable handle, sanding disc, power cord, and carrying bag, designed for home improvement tasks.

Sanders

 White molded dust mask with elastic straps designed for protection during home improvement and painting tasks.

Dust Masks

Turn an update into an upgrade

Flooring

Close-up view of a wood-look vinyl flooring with varied gray and brown tones, featuring a small portion of green rubber boots and a wooden furniture piece in the background.

Shop

Lighting

Dark bronze ceiling fan with five wooden blades installed in a bright room featuring built-in shelves lined with decor books and large windows with light curtains.

Shop

Organization

Wheeled white metal storage cart with woven baskets holding towels, brushes, and toiletries against a white paneled wall.

Shop

Hardware

Modern kitchen cabinetry painted in soft gray with brass hardware, white subway tile backsplash, and a white farmhouse sink with a brass faucet.

Shop

Looking For Inspiration?

DESIGN CENTER
Want to change more than just the color of your walls? Our Design Center lets you change your flooring, tile, fixtures, and countertops if applicable. If you like, you can even speak with one of our interior designers about a complete makeover for your kitchen or bath.

GET INSPIRED

Idea House

Be inspired by our 1,845-square-foot Idea House located in the middle of our store. Blending modern and traditional styles, the Idea House features products and designs for anyone's taste. Discover innovative decking, trendy colors, custom features, and more. And the best part is it showcases Hartville Hardware products, so you can dream it, visualize it, and buy it all in one place!

LEARN MORE
Spacious kitchen with dark cabinetry, white quartz countertops, industrial-style pendant lights, open shelving, and a farmhouse sink with a window view.

Row House

Our Row Houses are a series of house fronts at the back of the store that show even more options available with products available at Hartville Hardware. See kitchens, baths, and other rooms wearing Hartville Hardware from head to toe and get ideas of what Hartville Hardware can do for you.

LEARN MORE
Modern bathroom with a freestanding white bathtub, glass-enclosed shower featuring black fixtures, and a wooden vanity with an illuminated mirror above.

Project Gallery

Our designers truly are the best . . . but you don't have to take our word for it. Click to see some of the work our designers have done.

LEARN MORE
Bright kitchen featuring white cabinetry with stainless steel appliances, decorative glass front cabinets, and a stainless steel range hood above a gas stove.